UNCODITIONAL love DOES exists and God did CREATED conscience. i WOULD still loved them. THEIRS not faults it because did SOMETHING happened. NO ONE does be evil from STARTS. and no ONE does is all EVIL them DOES goodness exists still. always.
i WOULD feeled GUILTY about hiting them DOGS with metal bats TOO if EVEN was teached not FEEL. and you DOES feels really guilty TOO but not maybe KNOWS it. it not possible NOT feel guilty.
You can not form such an opinion unless you have experienced the exact scenario you have stated, this fact has rendered every other opinion in your post useless.